I don't know about your household, but in ours, octopuses (octopi?) reign supreme. Darsie has one stuffed creature that she adores...and it is an octopus dubbed "legs". When I saw these, I just thought they were cool, although they may be one of the strangest Etsy picks to date. Check out bunny X productions for interesting polymer creations.
Prior Etsy Picks
#1 KaraRee's Shop - the loveliest original acrylic, watercolor, and mixed-media creations
#2 Sudlow - the most gorgeous, beautiful, creative jewelry
#3 Seabreezestudio - great handmade purses, card holders, zippered pouches, etc.
#4 Mikeatron's - hilarious art prints
#5 Small Beans - adorable children's items
#6 Marymee Studio - beautiful ceramics
#7 Off Woodland Lane or Sign Language - family signs
#8 You and Your Little Brother - Funky stuffed creatures
#9 Annie's Sweatshop - eco-friendly dog accessories
#10 Elly Nelly - wall graphics
#11 Wooden Toys
#12 Serendipity: Beyond Design - wedding organization
#13 felted wool brooches - just what the "name" implies.
#14 Kneehighs-n-Pigtails Jewelry - beautiful jewelryPhatSheep - contemporary textile accessories
#17 studio m. - art prints
#18 Lemons and Lollis - sweet aand delectable kid duds.
#19 bloodybunny - lanyards, key holders, and other neat items